nutrition on the run

Shake Down

Dear Dr. Jo,
My favorite summertime treat is a chocolate hand-dipped ice cream shake at the local ice cream shop. They don't have nutritional information. Any idea how many calories are in my summer shakes?
Signed,
Crazy for Chocolate

Dear Chocolate,
I have a pretty good idea since I researched all sorts of beverages for my upcoming book, Dining Lean. While most of the fast food restaurant “shakes” contain about 200 to 300 calories per 8 fluid ounces, shakes that are promoted as “hand-dipped,” “hand-scooped” or “made with real ice cream” contain 400 to 600 calories (or more!) for the same amount.

Now, before you start with “oh, that's not too bad,” I don’t know of a single place that sells an 8 fluid ounce (1 cup) shake. That’s the size of one of those small styrofoam cups that are in the office break room or a typical fast food “kiddie” cup. Very small! Chances are your shake is twice as big—or bigger!

Here's a short summary of how chocolate shakes stack up at some of the chains:

  • Burger King Shake, 16 ounces = 470 calories, 14g fat
  • McDonald Triple Thick Shake, 16 ounces = 580 calories, 14g fat
  • Carl Jr or Hardees Hand Scooped Ice Cream Shakes, 16 ounces = 710 calories, 33g fat
  • Cold Stone Creamery Like-It Fudge PB&C, 12 ounces shake = 985 calories, 69g fat (NOTE: that's just 12 ounces!!)
Chances are your hand-dipped ice cream shake, if it’s just 16 ounces, contains at least 1,000 calories and 40+g fat. Is it worth it? Can you order a smaller size? Enjoy it less often? Share it with a friend?

Regarding calcium, I was a bit surprised that most shakes have quite a bit. BK has 35 percent DV (daily value, meaning that it contributes over a third of your calcium needs for the day), McDonald’s has 45 percent, the 12-ounce at Cold Stone Creamery, 50 percent!

P.S. I'm hoping you’re not adding “mixers” to your shake. That will probably add another 25 percent more calories.




Dr Jo is a PhD nutritionist and registered dietitian. Like you, she’s busy and is constantly on the search for healthy menu options (in restaurants) and grab ‘n go products (in the supermarket and convenience stores). She’s the author of three books: Dining Lean, Dr Jo’s No Big Deal Diet, and How to Stay Healthy & Fit on the Road. Dr Jo has appeared on 300+ TV and radio shows, presented more than 1000 programs at conferences, and has written articles or has been quoted in 200+ newspapers, magazines and websites. You can contact Dr Jo at 770-973-6242, drjo@drjo.com, or www.drjo.com.


Comments and Questions for Nutrition on the Run

There are no current discussions for this article. Why not be the first?

Post your comments on this article



Past Nutrition on the Run Articles

Recipes

Search for recipes. Enter an ingredient or keyword.

 

Recipes by Category

breakfast, lunch, dinner
dessert, snack, healthy

Recipes by Ingredient

beef, chicken, pork, poultry, turkey

newsletter & message boards

Fresh Recipes in your Inbox
Enjoy new meal ideas by signing up for our newsletter and see other recipe ideas in our past newsletters.


Swap Food Ideas
Share your favorite recipe or comment on our latest issue in our food & recipe message boards.

our new cookbook

relish cookbook

where to find relish

Relish magazine is distributed monthly through newspapers across the country. To find a partner paper near you, take a look at our list of newspapers by state. If you local paper does not carry Relish, ask them why not?