Here are some of the current comments about this recipe. To read more or post your own comments,
Step # 3 doesn't make sense to me. Am I missing something? Step #1 you mix the starter you have prepared previously with some water and flour. You then let it stand for 8 hours. Step #2 is combining your yeast, water, and sugar. Then step #3 states that you should, "Place flour mixture in the bowl of a stand mixture." Not only does that sentence not make sense, but what flour mixture would that be? At this point I only have a mixture of dough which has risen over night and the yeast mixture that I just created. What am I missing?
joshknoedler
10/11/09 3:17 PM
Greetings
New here, but saw your post and thought I might be of some help. I agree, that the instructions are a bit confusing, and likely a misprint.
My guess would be that what they intend for you to do is add the additional 2c flour to the mixture you let stand overnite.(Note the recipe indicated 5-7c flour). Now it does go on to say to add up to 2c additional flour, but I would assume that will be very likely needed to make the dough workable.
It's been some time since I have made sourdough, but being the air has taken a decided chill, I see it in the near future. Hope this helps, and if not, and you went another way, please feel free to let me know.
zentropa
10/12/09 11:33 AM
Step #6 is missing also...seems like it might be a typo but as a beginner with sourdough starter I wanted to find out b4 I got off to an even more "sour" start.
J Devore
10/20/09 9:00 AM
Instructions: 1. Combine 1 cup sourdough starter, 2 cups water and 5 cups flour in a large bowl. Mix well; cover with a dish towel and let rise 8 hours or overnight.
2. Combine yeast, 1/4 cup warm water, and 1/2 teaspoon sugar. Let stand 5 minutes, until mixture bubbles.
3. Place flour mixture in the bowl of a stand mixer. Add yeast mixture, salt and remaining 1 1/2 teaspoons sugar. Mix well. With your hands or a dough hook, knead while gradually adding up to 2 additional cups of flour, 1/2 cup at a time. Knead until a smooth, soft dough forms. Dough should be shiny and supple.
Explanation: The flour mixture we're referring to in step 3 is the flour, starter and water you've mixed together in step 1.
So in step 3, you're putting the flour mixture in a mixing bowl. Then you add the yeast mixture (from step 2) , 2 teaspoons of salt and the remaining 1 1/2 teaspoons sugar. Using an stand mixer fitted with a dough hook, you then knead the bread, adding up to 2 more cups of flour.
I've been making this bread weekly since July. What I've found works well is the combine 1 cup starter, 2 cups water, and 4 or 5 cups flour in the bowl that goes with my stand mixer. Then when I get to step 3, the "flour mixture" is already in the bowl that I'm going to knead in.
Does this help???
The Relish Editors
10/21/09 12:07 PM
Well, step 6 isn't missing--we just can't count! (Blame it on the yeasty mixture that's floating around.)
I've corrected the recipe on our website.
Please keep us posted about your progress with the bread. I've been making it weekly since July. Instead of making 2 large loaves, I've been dividing the dough in thirds lately. I keep 2 loaves and give 1 away each week.
The Relish Editors
10/21/09 12:30 PM
Part of the problem with this recipe may be that some of the words are mixed. In the original recipe and in the editor's correction the word "mixture" is used where they should have used "mixer". The "stand mixture" and "electric mixture" are the same "mixer".
Dick
11/19/09 9:08 PM
Thank you, Dick.
I've edited my explanation a bit and fixed the mixture-mixer snafus.
The Relish Editors
11/20/09 11:31 AM
Post your comments on this recipe